Showing posts with label Penn State University. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Penn State University. Show all posts

Thursday, November 10, 2011

The Power of Sports in the College Landscape


In the fall out of the Penn State scandal, a lot of people are asking whether sports have too much power. This is in response, there has been a particularly a backlash against the students, who have marched in support of Joe Paterno. A couple days ago, I defended the students:
As an alum of a big sports school, I'll defend the kids, not for supporting Joe, but wanting to hold onto the football program. Sports are a big part of the experience at any big time football school. A big part of that is winning. These kids are confused and they're in denial because they're losing something that is dear to them. I'm sure many of them have a great fondness for the program and what JoePa has done for the Penn State football program on the field. Many of them grew up rooting for this team, watching teams like the undefeated 1994 team (I guess these kids might have been too young for that, huh?) or the many other strong Penn State squads of the last 15-20 years. JoePa has been very influential in making their school what it is because of the football program's winning tradition. The football program is a huge source of pride at Penn State. JoePa stepping down is a huge loss to the program and the university. These kids are losing a part of what makes them whole.

In time, they'll understand the wrongdoings of Paterno, but they'll need time to digest the reality and magnitude of what went on.
It's still too early for students to understand what happened. What happened was serious. What happened is ongoing. What happened will have consequences. I still understand why the kids acted the way they did. That doesn't mean I agree with them, but I understand. I felt the same way when I heard about "Practicegate," something that seems extremely small compared to what went on at Penn State. I was in denial. I didn't want something bad to happen at my school. Sports at my school meant so much to me.

The question is do sports have too much power?

I think sports are a great vehicle by which school pride can manifest itself. There aren't many way where you can show your school is better than the other school. Sports allows that. It's become a big business at schools and some schools do give it preferential treatment. That's the bigger problem.

What happened at Penn State, and we're still finding out more every day, was a lack of transparency and a lack of clear-minded thinking. Everything was addressed through the chain of command rather than where it should have been, by the law. The problem isn't with sports. The problem is when sports get special treatment to operate above the laws, not only of the NCAA but also of the land. Penn State had a chance to address these allegations immediately and properly. Now, they will have to face the consequences of their inaction.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Yeah I've Got To: Conference Alignment

So you're sitting at home, reading sports news, you see all these schools desperate to join all these conference, but you don't see the Big Ten mentioned at all. Instantly, you panic. What the hell is going on? Why are we sitting back and doing nothing? Why aren't we going after these schools?

Well, do we really need to?

From a Big Ten and Michigan standpoint, not really:

The Big Ten has the three most popular teams in college football, so they can afford to wait as far as conference realignment goes. It doesn't make sense for them to go after schools left and right, when they already have a good base. Everyone says to go after Notre Dame and Texas, but if you're going to expand, it's going to be an even number of schools. Additionally, it's going to lead to more of a split if you do bring in more schools in terms of TV revenue. I don't think it makes sense for Notre Dame or Texas to come to the Big Ten at the moment, nor does it make sense for us to take them on.

If you really do want to expand, it's all about strategy. The crown jewel of college sports, despite the fact that it's not as big a college football market as one thinks is New York. Everyone wants into New York. So what about New York?

The Big Ten already has 3 of the top 10 most popular teams in New York. I really think they'll only benefit if they bring in a Notre Dame or a Rutgers if they want to expand. Rutgers might not be worth it because the increase in subscriptions might be offset by the fact that there is another mouth to feed. Notre Dame really is the only one that makes sense from a competitive and financial perspective. The problem is that they won't want to come to the Big Ten if they come in because of their current deal with NBC.

They're not Michigan, they're not Ohio State, and they're not Penn State.

I don't think I want the Big Ten to expand otherwise. Brian Bennett of ESPN spells it out. It doesn't make sense for the Big Ten to take on Missouri or Kansas for the sake of expansion. They don't bring anything to the table in terms of competition or financial benefits, but they're AAU schools which fit in if there is expansion.

Honestly, the Big Ten is in good shape. They got a good school in Nebraska that actually brings something to the table. They might miss out on Texas and Notre Dame, but neither schools would want to fit into the Big Ten when you look at the Big Ten Network. With all the expansion, everyone wants the Big Ten to get in on it too, but I believe staying true and keeping things the way they are might be the best thing to do.

Right now, the Big Ten has a great TV deal and a great network that does well to give exposure to all the schools. They already have some great brand names under their moniker. There is no need to try and bring more mouths under their roof at the moment. Even with all of this expansion, the Big Ten will continue to thrive in its current state.